|
|
. |
Is
Sitting Behind Your Computer Helping or Harming Your Brain?
The explosion of digital
technology is not only changing the way we live and communicate but it is
also altering our brains. Daily exposure to high technology –
computers, mobile phones, blackberries, video games, search engines like Google –
have become a way of life for most people. These
technologies stimulate brain cell alteration and neurotransmitter
release, gradually strengthening new neural pathways in our brains
while weakening old ones. Because of the current technological
revolution, our brains are evolving at this moment at a speed
previously unknown!
Daily Technology Use
We use digital technology for entertainment, communication, discu ssion, and for
keeping up with friends/relatives/colleagues. As the brain evolves and
shifts towards adapting to new technological skills, it drifts away from
more fundamental social skills. These include reading facial
expressions during a chat, or grasping the more emotional context of a
subtle gesture. Here are some of the facts and figures:
• For every hour we spend on our computers,
traditional face-to-face interaction time with other people drops by
nearly 30 minutes (2002 Stanford University study).
• From 1000 children followed on a typical day:
o 75% watch TV, with 32% of these watching DVDs or
videos
o Daily exposure time to TV/DVD/video was 1 hour 20
minutes
o 5-6 year olds spend an extra 50 minutes in front of
the computer
(2007 University of Texas at Austin study)
• Young people aged between 8-18 years old expose
their brains to 8.5 hours of digital and video stimulation every day
including:
o 4 hours is passive (watching TV/videos)
o 1.45 hours is passive (listening to music)
o 50 mins is active (playing video games)
o 1 hour is active (using the computer)
(2005 Kaiser Family Foundation study)
The brain’s neural
circuitry responds every moment to whatever sensory input it gets. This means
that the many hours we spend in front of the computer
- surfing around on the internet, emailing, on-line shopping – expose
our brains to constant digital stimulation. Today’s young
people in their teens and 20s have
been born into a world in which they only know 24-hour TV, internet,
mobile phones, digital cameras and text messaging. They rarely go into
libraries or use a real book encyclopaedia to look up information
(I am sounding almost like a dinosaur here!). The neural networks of
these ‘digital natives’ (as they have been called), differs
dramatically from those who came into the digital age as adults and
teenagers (they have been called ‘digital immigrants’). In this
group their basic brain wiring was laid down during a time when direct
social interaction was the norm.
How Quickly Can The
Brain Adapt?
A group of researchers at UCLA (California) decided to look at just how
much impact this computer time was having on the brain wiring – and as
to how quickly the brain can build up new pathways. They used fMRI
(functional magnetic resonance imaging, otherwise known as brain
scanning) to compare the brains of computer naives (i.e people who were
relatively inexperienced and naive to computers) to computer savvies
(i.e people who were experienced with computers). The biggest
problem they had was not a technical one, but was in being able to
recruit people who had very little knowledge of computers!
The savvies and the
naives were placed in the MRI scanner and given a simple
internet search task to do, whilst their brain was being scanned to see
if there were any differences in the groups. They were also asked to
read a book whilst in the scanner, as a sort of ‘control test’. The naives were then
told to go and practice surfing on the internet for 1 hour a day for 5
days, and then report back for the second brain scan. Again, both
groups were scanned whilst doing an internet search task, and whilst
reading a book.
The results were fascinating. In the first scan, there were no
differences between the groups whilst
reading the book. However, during the internet surfing task, the
savvies had much more activity in the dorsal prefrontal cortex. This
area is involved in the ability to make decisions and integrate complex
information. It is also thought to control our metal process of
integrating sensations and thoughts, as well as working (short-term)
memory.
The brain scan following the 5-day gap during which the naives
practiced for 1 hour a day, revealed that that same dorsal prefrontal
cortex area was now as active. The computer savvies’ brain activity was
similar between the 2 scans suggesting that once the brain rewiring
takes place it remains stable. What is incredible is that after just 5
hours on the internet the computer naives had already rewired their
brains!
Continuous Partial
Attention and Techno-Brain Burnou t
The hi-tech revolution has plunged us into a state of continuous
connectedness. One the one had this sounds good, but people often get into a
state always being busy and keeping tabs on everything that they don’t truly
focus on anything. This has been termed ‘continuous partial attention’.
Although being connected to friends, family and colleagues online can
seem intimate and connected we do risk losing that personal touch with
our real-life relationships as compared to devoting our attention to
one individual at a time.
Paying continuous partial attention has been shown to place the brain
in a heightened state of stress. The person does not have time to
reflect, contemplate or make
thoughtful decisions. Our brains were not built to sustain such
monitoring for extended periods of time. Eventually the hours of
unrelenting digital connectivity can create a unique type of brain
strain….feelings of being space out, fatigued, irritable, distracted
and ‘foggy’ sensations. The result is a sort of techno-brain burnout
:=( Under this kind of stress, our brains instinctively signal the
adrenal glands to secrete cortisol and adrenaline. The stress hormones
boost energy levels and improve memory, but overtime they actually
impair cognition, lead to depression, and alter the neural circuitry in
the amygdala, hippocam pus and prefrontal
cortex (brain regions which control mood and thought). Chronic and
prolonged techno-brain burnout can even reshape the underlying brain
structure!
However, there is an antidote. Another study (form Harvard) found that
varying the type of tasks you undertake, and having a break in between,
refreshed and reinvigorated the brain. The optimum break involved a
60-minute sleep, since this is the time it takes for the REM (Rapid Eye
Movement) sleep to kick in.
The Good Effects of
Computers
But are computers all doom and gloom for our brains & social lives?
No, they certainly are not.
Here are some of the characteristics that working with computers have
been shown positively affect:
• Reacting more quickly to visual stimuli
• Improvement in different forms of attention
• Improved ability to notice images in our peripheral
vision
• Better ability to sift through large amounts of
information
• IQs have been rising with advancing digital culture
• Some computer games can improve cognitive ability and
multi-tasking skills (ha ,ha, this one must only be for men…!)
The Scales of Balance
So maybe the answer – as with most things in life – is finding the
BALANCE. The neural circuits allow us to rapid-fire our way through
piles of information, but it is also important to maintain and improve our personal
contact and ‘people skills’ too. Only in this way will we be able to
have the best of both worlds by being able to not only take advantage
of the efficiency and speed of technology, but also the slow-old-world
effectiveness of true empathic listening and connection.
And with that final computer keystroke, I am going into the garden for
a spot of good old-fashioned book reading :=)
|
|